Internet Explorer 7 vs. Firefox 2

---

---

 JUDGES: Peter Butler, Rafe Needleman, and Elsa Wenzel

 

For years, Microsoft Internet Explorer has enjoyed near dominance of the Web browser space--but not any more. Since the release last year of Mozilla Firefox 1.5, Firefox has been steadily eroding Internet Explorer's claim of superiority. According to information from NetApplications.com, in October 2004 Internet Explorer had 92 percent of the market; in September 2005 that dropped to 86 percent; and as of September 2006 Internet Explorer's market share dropped to 82 percent, with Firefox's rising to 12.5 percent. In two years Microsoft ceded 10 percent of its audience to its competition.

So how do the latest versions of each browser compare? For this prizefight, we looked at Microsoft Internet Explorer 7, Microsoft's first new Internet browser since 2001, and Mozilla Firefox 2, Mozilla's update of its popular Firefox 1.5 browser released in November 2005. I've already had my two cents' in the above reviews, so I've turned over this prizefight to my colleagues at CNET who specifically cover the Web services beat.

About the judges

Rafe Needleman, editor at large for CNET, covers new online applications and is launching a new CNET Web site about them: Webware.com.

Peter Butler is senior editor for CNET in charge of Download.com reviews.

Elsa Wenzel is an associate editor for CNET who reviews hulking office suites, tiny apps, and Web services.

 

 

 

 

Round 1: Installation woes

Firefox 2
Here's where we examine the overall process of upgrading or installing the two browsers. Our individual judges' ratings are based on a 0-to-5-point scale, which results in a final score of 0 to 15 per round.

Player	Rafe	Peter	Elsa	Total
Internet Explorer 7	2 Installing IE 7 requires a reboot and takes forever. Plus the download is giant, and you have to turn off your virus scanner. My installation went smoothly, but I got the feeling IE was reprogramming my computer's DNA as it worked.	1 The IE 7 installer asks users to temporarily disable their antivirus and antispyware protection, which doesn't inspire confidence. Installing IE 7 requires Windows validation, a restart, and a connection to Microsoft servers, which significantly slows down the process.	2 IE 7's installation recommended that we back up important files, close all programs, and eventually restart, while Firefox asked us only to close the old Firefox. And Microsoft checked that we were running a valid copy of Windows XP before we could download IE 7, which felt intrusive (if not insulting) next to the hands-off Firefox installation. But I'm not crazy about IE 7 or Firefox creating browser icons by default for my Windows XP desktop, Start Menu folder, and Quick Launch bar; you'll have to uncheck those during installation if you don't want the shortcuts.	5
Firefox 2	5 Firefox, on the other hand, is a small download and installs in about 30 seconds, no reboots or gene sequencing required.	4 Installation of Firefox 2 was much faster and easier, completing in a minute or two. It scanned my old version for incompatible extensions, then updated any that were available. Firefox 2 did not include my custom-created search engines, only those defaulted by Mozilla. Any custom engines need to be manually moved into the Searchplugins directory.	4 Firefox was a faster download, plus it migrated every toolbar and all but one of my dozen bookmarklets from Firefox 1 without a hitch.	13

Winner: Firefox 2

		Round 1	Round 2	Round 3	Round 4	Round 5
	IE 7
	Firefox	X

 

 

 

 

                         

 

Round 2: Look and community

Which browser looks and feels the best?

Firefox 2
Here's where we look at navigation, as well as overall look and feel. But the online world is rapidly becoming a community. Which browser best embodies the community aspect of the Web?

Player	Rafe	Peter	Elsa	Total
Internet Explorer 7	4 The two browsers both look very good. IE 7 is a bit slicker than Firefox, and it takes more chances with the interface, pushing the standard menu items off to the side. It may take users a few moments to learn where everything is, but it is a thoughtful redesign.	4 Departing from the classic look of version 6 by hiding the menu bar, IE 7 allots more space to the main browser window. The full-screen view is particularly well designed--tabs and the address bar disappear until you hover over them, creating a true full-screen window. The tabs are clunkier than necessary.	4 Internet Explorer's status as the browser people love to hate is unlikely to change anytime soon. IE 7's drastic redesign is likely to alienate users initially rather than wow them, even though it's now easier to find functions via graphical icons--once you stop looking for the now-gone drop-down menus of its predecessor. IE 7 thoughtfully offers more customization than in the past, such as the ability to add more search engines to its search field.	12
Firefox 2	5 Firefox doesn't have a radical visual refresh, but it does have some new UI features, such as a "word wheel" in the search bar. Firefox destroys IE in the extension and plug-in department. There are hundreds of tools for Firefox to enable all manner of customizing. IE has extensions too, but not like Firefox.	5 Hovering over a tab in Firefox 2 now highlights it, and each tab has its own close button, which was previously possible only with add-ons. Most themes aren't yet available for Firefox, but one of my favorites, Littlefox, works OK. Selecting a new theme now prompts Firefox to ask whether you want to restart the browser to see the effects. Customization for Firefox 2 via add-ons is a major bonus.	5 Firefox's open-source status and myriad add-ons give it a community edge over IE 7.	15

Winner: Firefox 2

		Round 1	Round 2	Round 3	Round 4	Round 5
	IE 7
	Firefox	X	X

Round 3: Tabbed browsing

They both have it; who does it better?

Firefox 2
Tabbed browsing has become a part of the Internet browser world. Microsoft just added it to Internet Explorer 7, but Mozilla has had it in Firefox for years. Which one implements this feature the best?

Player	Rafe	Peter	Elsa	Total
Internet Explorer 7	4 With the latest versions, both browsers treat tabs similarly. You can close tabs with their own little close boxes and open new tab windows by clicking in the tab bar (IE 7 makes it more obvious by displaying a tiny, empty tab). Both highlight the active tab subtly (too subtly for my taste), and let you drag tabs around and save open tabs. Differences: Firefox makes it easy to reload all tabs; IE has a thumbnail viewer.	3 IE 7 includes a New Tab button to the right of your last open tab that takes up unnecessary screen space. I couldn't find a way to remove it. IE 7 bunches two Favorites icons, all open tabs, and the standard browser toolbar in the same row of real estate. A helpful tab preview icon displays thumbnails of all your open tabs for any window.	4 Is it my imagination, or does Firefox open a new tab about a millisescond faster than IE 7 does? At the same time, IE 7's blank tab can help users discover tabbed browsing.	11
Firefox 2	4 One change in Firefox 2 that is a step backward from the last version: If you open a lot of tabs, Firefox shrinks their size a little and puts arrows at the left and right of the tab bar so that you can scroll back and forth. The previous version shrunk tabs a lot, so you could fit many more into the tab bar. I'm dinging Firefox's score for that one. IE 7 has the same problem.	4 Firefox adds a new Close Tab button to each open tab but didn't add thumbnail previews (a feature that can be added via Firefox extension). It would be nice to incorporate more features from Tab Mix Plus, such as the ability to customize how Ctrl-Tab switches tabs.	5 Firefox's tiny drop-down menu next to its tabs is a convenient shortcut for finding recently viewed pages, and its layout offers more room for tabs--although once we had a dozen tabs open, we were forced to scroll awkwardly to view the thirteenth tab and beyond. Luckily, though, if Firefox crashes, you can restore those tabs, which IE 7 can't do.	13

Winner: Firefox 2

		Round 1	Round 2	Round 3	Round 4	Round 5
	IE 7
	Firefox	X	X	X

Round 4: Cool new features

Which new feature rocks?

Firefox 2
Microsoft had five years to dream up a new Internet browser; Mozilla's been updating its popular Firefox browser pretty regularly in the last few years. Which offers the coolest new features?

Player	Rafe	Peter	Elsa	Total
Internet Explorer 7	3 There are fancy little flourishes in both browsers (IE has page zoom; Firefox has a spelling checker), but the big news in new browser features right now is RSS reading. Both browsers recognize when a page has an RSS feed, and both will parse XML and display a readable page instead of code when they see it.	3 RSS feeds: Once you've subscribed to a feed via IE 7, it's easy to see, sort, manage, and read your subscriptions from a two-panel interface. Firefox's Live Bookmarks do a similar job, but not as neatly. I only wish IE 7 detected available feeds better.	3 Neither IE 7 nor Firefox do a terrific job of showing off their new features. Many of IE 7's new features are old tricks for Firefox. At least IE 7's RSS icon gave us a hint about its ability to surface newsfeeds; that icon appears within the Firefox address bar only when you land at a Web site with an RSS feed. But once we subscribed to some feeds, we couldn't find them within IE 7. Firefox, on the other hand, displayed them by default on a toolbar and within its Bookmarks folder.	9
Firefox 2	4 Firefox does a much better job of managing feeds: It will let you subscribe in Firefox's own reader, which awkwardly makes bookmarks of headlines, or in Google, Bloglines, Yahoo, or any reader application you have on your PC. IE will subscribe itself only to feeds, and it doesn't display RSS content as reliably as Firefox.	3 In Firefox 2, I love the Manage Search Engines dialog, but I'd say the Session Saver feature is the biggest improvement. I know that many people who accidentally quit the browser will love it.	4 Firefox's RSS features are even more flexible since (as Rafe mentions) they can let you subscribe with a third-party newsreader. Overall, however, I found the RSS features somewhat clumsy in both browsers and easy for RSS newbies to overlook. IE 7's easy ability to zoom in on a Web page makes for better browsing if you have vision problems. Ctrl-T does the same trick within Firefox, but most users may not memorize such keyboard shortcuts. Firefox also checks your spelling, which could save you from embarrassing yourself in a hasty e-mail or blog post.	11

Winner: Firefox 2

		Round 1	Round 2	Round 3	Round 4	Round 5
	IE 7
	Firefox	X	X	X	X

Round 5: Security and performance

Which browser do you trust?

Firefox 2
You can't surf the Web these days without fretting about online villains eager to take your money or your identity. Which browser offers the best?

Player	Rafe	Peter	Elsa	Total
Internet Explorer 7	3 I have to defer to security gurus in this category. Historically I've been impressed with how seamless installing security patches to Firefox has been. As far as privacy, both products now let you quickly erase tracks from your browser, which is good.	4 A phishing filter within IE 7 checks the Web pages you visit using heuristics and a whitelist of legitimate sites. IE 7 lets you clean out your history, temporary files, and Web cookies with one button, but it's not easy to delete specific files in those groups. Another nice browsing-security touch is the "Web page privacy policy" feature. The past history of exploitable security holes in IE is a factor to consider.	3 At least during setup, IE 7 appears to care about security by giving you the choice to install a phishing filter. Firefox doesn't make its security offerings obvious during setup. Both browsers allow you to clear cookie crumbs that show the sites you've seen, but we found such features tricky to find within IE 7's new interface.	10
Firefox 2	3 Firefox makes it a one-click operation, though, which is much better. On the other hand, it's far too easy to reveal all your stored passwords in Firefox. You can put (another) password in front of this feature, but most people won't, leaving their passwords easily visible to anybody who gets on to their PC.	4 Also adding antiphishing measures, Firefox 2 offers a choice to check sites from a preexisting blacklist or via Google. Firefox 2 also offers more customization than IE 7, letting you specify which warning messages you'll receive and allowing you to view all your cookies in a list.	5 Firefox's stronger reputation for security and Mozilla's practice of addressing vulnerabilities soon after they're discovered precedes its latest update.	12

Winner: Firefox 2

		Round 1	Round 2	Round 3	Round 4	Round 5
	IE 7
	Firefox	X	X	X	X	X

The winner is...

Firefox 2 Total points
Internet Explorer 7: 47
Firefox 2: 64
Winner: Firefox 2


Firefox 2 still rules the browser roost for now, despite a much improved version of Internet Explorer. The most obvious new feature for IE 7 (tabs) has been in Firefox forever, and the security additions from Microsoft aren't enough for us to allay concerns over new possible exploits. Lastly, the extensibility of Firefox 2 is its knockout punch, and IE's add-ons cannot compare. The flexibility and customizability of Firefox might be best suited to more advanced Web users, but it has earned its spot at the top of the browsers.

		Round 1	Round 2	Round 3	Round 4	Round 5
	IE 7
	Firefox	X	X	X	X	X

Firefox vs Internet Explorer